POP: Aussie goes down under on Idol! New POD!, Beth and Val!

A few quick hits:

Download me now, or you’ll be sorry!

Just a reminder, you can now listen to or download a new episode of the PopPod (which might be changing its name to PopCast, patent pending). As always, you can either find it here or to the side of the PopPulse main.

We teamed up with Jeff Vrabel, the editor of The Guide, and Liz Farrell, who runs he Island Packet's InCrowd blog, for this half hour look at the absurdity of pop.

This week, we’ve cut the price in half to zero for the full 30 minutes, so you can’t be that savings. Unless we paid you to listen to it. Which we’re thinking about doing.



This week: Biz Markie, Marilyn Manson, Alice Cooper, Jay-Z and more.

America: Go back to Australia you freak!

Last night’s American Idol was quite a shocker. We, for one, were sadden to see the Australian lug Michael Johns go. Even though he was mediocre most weeks, he was at least interesting to listen to. And he provided (we thought) a real challenge to David “We really can’t stand you nor do we understand why anyone thinks you can sing when you obviously can’t you lip-licking weirdo” Archuletta.



His ouster proved four things we’ve known all along:

1. America is fickle, as Johns had the week previous provided the ONLY highlight in the otherwise dreadful Dolly Parton night. Seriously, whose idea was this, and can we fire them? We can name only two Parton songs, and no one even sang 9-to-5. We really, really hated that night, although Johns was the only one to remotely come off better than he started. This, kids, is a great performance:


2. Country music fans will listen to ANYTHING! This has been our mantra for the last year, since we started this blog. Country fans routinely prop up talentless Idol contestants because they will support anything. Joshua Gracin. Bucky. Kelly Pickler. Kristie Lee Cook. All HORRIBLE. The exception is Carrie Underwood, who has talent. HOW IS COOK STILL IN THIS CONTEST!?!? She stinks.

3. Americans are obviously racist when it comes to Australians. This is clear.

4. You vote for the person you want to win, not the one you hate (which is not how it should be). So contestants who aren’t spectacular (or who go first, making them forgettable) are in trouble every week. Ditto if you get a mediocre review from the judges. (Better to be trashed, for the sympathy, or praised.)

And while we’re talking about Idol, we want to reiterate what we wrote about last year: We think Idol Gives Back stinks. And we hate it.

First, Idol doesn’t give back, we do. Idol makes billions world round and could give back, of course. Those horrible iTunes performances, for instance, it sells to you, it could give 100 percent of those profits to charity. As it could that horrible touring stage show. It could give 10% of ad revenue to charity, if it wanted. But, no, it wants YOU to give to ITS charity (all while selling commercials for a bloated special that gets ratings and drives up the sponsor fees). Do we not give Idol enough just by watching? Now it hits up its audiences to give even more, all the while making us feel guilty for, what?, for watching a horrible TV show that is overproduced. Trust us, we already feel guilty for that.

Jonesing Lost?

In case you’re missing Lost, EW has a report from the set of the show. Lots of tidbits to follow.

Beth and Val

Here is this week’s PopPulse Recommends column, which you can find weekly in the Guide:

We are always on the backside of trends. Like, we jump on right after the bandwagon stops to let off all of its passengers. The only people left on it are us, some old dude in Kansas and a kid whose parents just now let him watch R-rated movies.

And it’s not because we’re too-cool-for-the-room, it’s because we’re slow to embrace anything that we didn’t find first. If we were hanging with Ponce de Leon after he discovered Florida, no matter how much he tried to convince us to come visit, we’d refuse. “No, it’s cool. We’ll just hang over here in Alabama.”

Anyway, we found this digital show called “Ask Anything With Beth and Val.” It’s an online vlog, which is a video blog. (Which is also a term that means nothing, because even though it’s called a “vlog” there’s nothing remotely bloggy about it. Like, the two women don’t stare into the camera and talk about their day.)

(Warning, the language in the links might be spicy.)



The concept is people write questions and the two actresses/writers/comedians riff for three minutes, staring into the camera, playing off each other, taking the initial question into tangents and bizarre areas. It’s an incredibly basic concept that works because the two women are wickedly smart and really, really funny. And, it turns out, that is the key to having a humorous three-minute comedy bit.



And we’re pretty sure these two are some underground internet sensation. And we’re almost certain they haven’t already apexed with delirious ‘net fan sites and MySpace devotees, because when we Googled their names, we got very few responses. So, let us drive the bandwagon for once!



Topics have included celebrities and who is prettier and what animal could you beat up. On the subject of who is prettier, Beth said, “It depends on who you’re talking to.” Val: “If you’re talking to me, then I’m much hotter. But if you’re talking to Beth ...” Beth: “Then SHE’S hotter. Because I have no self esteem.”

Comments

Kristi Lee: Vote for the Worst - Sanjaya 2008 but much cuter. At least from a guy perspective. As good a singer as Sanjaya too.

Dolly Parton Night: Some one, Some where, was smoking something really really, yes, REALLY, good to have come up with this idea. Whats next? Michael Jackson Invite A Sixth Grader Night?

David Johns: He was leaving eventually - whats it matter if its this week or week 93?

Brooke White: Why isn't she singing Mary Chapin Carpenter, John Gorka, Joni Mitchell - some folk singer. She is clearly a folk singer - BE a folk singer.

Carly Smithson - soon to be gone. What's with the face on her arm? Thats just weird. Did you see her boyfriend, he's even worse. Together they probably deliver for fedex in their day jobs. I thought Irish girls were cute and had red hair - and no faces on their arms.

Jason Castro - the female version of Kristi Lee Cook - would never think of singing a Lee Greenwood song. Will also be gone once talent actually matters. Can he beat box? I do like Israel Kamakawiwo'ole - though he destroyed Iz' version of Somewhere Under the Rainbow - Hey' you got Poi?

Syesha - hasn't she already won? Somebody just like her won once, right? Anyway, she aint gonna win - not enough of the Middle School teeny-bopper vote.

Who's left? Oh yeah, Archuleta and Cook. Are they REALLY different people? Archuleta is the favorite right now - see why Syesha will not win for why he might. He lacks the David Cassidy thing though. Kind of a doofus and sooner or later cool wins out with the teenage girls who "vote like three hundred times for David, oooh, I was up until 3 am trying to get through, like it was amazing hearing his voice."

Why Country Music Fans Will Listen to Anything: One word. Rap. Urban music, hip hop. Ok, thats 5 or 6, but you get the point. Country music is where white mainstream rock and roll went to die. Every once in a while you get a rock country song, then it goes back to waaaa waaaa waaa. Waa. Does anyone REALLY think that REO Speedwagon, Journey, Pink Floyd, Billy Joel or Boston would have had a chance today? Just LOOK at - Tom Petty - you know that face just wouldn't work in video if he was trying to get a contract today.

Idol Gives Back: You mean I'm not a loser scumbag if I don't send them money - oh it makes me feel so good to know I'm making a difference. You think they flew Simon and Seacrest to Africa in First Class? Or maybe it was chartered jet all the way with beds and champagne? One bed or two? Being a cynic is a bad thing I've been told.

Lost: I think I should have Tivo's the 3 season retrospective since I have no idea whats going on any more - and I watched all the eps this year.

Speaking of TIVO: American Idol lasts 27 minutes if you only listen to the songs and then the criticism. Less time than a sitcom. Further, I only watch the last 8 minutes of the Results show. Do I REALLY want to see how they sang or that Dolly Parton is now old and still can't sing? That means I start the Idol show on TIVO at 8.15p on Thurs night, watch all the singing, have time to delete the show, go to the bathroom, return, sit down, see who is in the bottom 3 or 2 or whatever, and then see who leaves. 38 minutes, includes a potty break and the loser. Done.


joefarrell's picture
Posted by joefarrell - Fri, 2008-04-11 17:43

Good thoughts. Although we're less harsh on the hippie's take on Somewhere Over the Rainbow. We liked it. Even though we're certain the kid is constantly baked.

And Carly, hey, lighten up. Why always so angry? She needs to send The Sun Will Come Out Tomorrow or something similarly light and fluffy.

We watch Idol in about 20 minutes, because it's rare that we need to hear the entire song. And we FF through Paula and, usually, Randy. And, of course, Seacrest. But it's actually 40 minutes, because we have to stop every minute to yell something at our screen.


poppulse's picture
Posted by poppulse - Fri, 2008-04-11 19:31

I also liked Jason Castro's version of Somewhere..Rainbow, but his facial expressions make me nervous. I also agree that he is totally baked. Don't FF through Paula, watch American pharmaceuticals at their best.


Posted by claudia42282 - Fri, 2008-04-11 23:15

Why do we keep watching AI?
For some of us, it's a job. But why do millions of people STILL tune in for this crap?
For anyone clinging to Pascal's Wager for hope in the eternal afterlife, AI is definitive proof that there is, in fact, no God.
If God existed, he'd have dropped some Old Testament retribution on AI in a hurry.
Obviously that's not happened, which leads me to believe that either God is dead, God has left the building for a wicked game of inter-planar Yahtzee!, or that we are all, actually, in Hell.
I'm really leaning towards the last bit. How else to explain all the God-awful crud on television, film and music these days?
Feel free to drive the bandwagon on this Hell theory, Mr. PopPulse.


Posted by Godzilla74 - Mon, 2008-04-14 14:48

I am happy to say I have never watched more than about 3 minutes without throwing the remote or pounding the channel change button.....rates right up there with dancing with the stars, big brother and the rest of the ****. Thank gawd for the history and discovery channels.......


Posted by classidiot - Mon, 2008-04-14 15:05

Wow, are we the only ones who ENJOY how cheesy awful the show is? Try not to take it so seriously. We firmly believe 50 percent of the audience are teenage girls and 50 percent are dudes like us who watch and laugh and yell things at the screen. It's like football, but pitchy.

P.S. And let's not get carried away with the "TV is horrible these days" nonsense. We just have MORE of it, but TV has always been a mix of great and truly horrible. The problem is, we romanticize all of the horrible shows pre-1990. If we were to argue how bad A-Team, Six Million Dollar Man, Dance Fever, Who's the Boss?, Growing Pains, Alice, Fall Guy, et all TRULY were, we'd have a riot in here.


poppulse's picture
Posted by poppulse - Mon, 2008-04-14 17:31

Woo, woo, woo, woo, woo, woo, woo, woo, woo!
Here comes the Hyperbole Police - they're going to lock you up in Exaggeration-traz!
A riot? A riot, you say?
All of those pre-1990 shows combined have not collectively done the kind of damage to American viewer intelligence than one season of "Idol."
Are you kidding me?
Yes, those shows were pure cheese, but if art is imitating life, then at least back then all our problems could be wrapped up with a tidy 28-minute show where the guy gets the girl, the bad guys didn't get away, and everyone was laughing.
Today, if art imitates life, then what does "Idol" have to say about us?
I can't stand the mirror image that "Idol" reflects back upon me. And as much as I despise it for what it is - glorified karaoke - I'm still partly responsible for allowing its continued existence.
"American Idol" is a juggernaut of crap, which has soiled all of us, and given nothing back that can begin to make up for its transgressions.
I'd dare you to name just ONE thing, ONE redeeming quality of "Idol." And, no, you can't count Daughtry - he was already a great singer and performer before he joined the show.
Why should "Idol" continue to exist? At least when I ask myself why Hollywood should continue to exist, there are a few films and shows that rekindle my dimming faith in humanity. But there's nothing I can say the same for about "Idol."


Posted by Godzilla74 - Tue, 2008-04-15 14:28

I hate to play the family card, because I don't like to, but American Idol is 60 minutes of harmless fluff that parents can sit around and watch with their kids without fear of sex or drugs or (most nights) rock n roll. As crusty and as bitter as you are, even you can see that, at the end of the day, it's HARMLESS. There's your one redeeming quality.

Here's another: And, to boot, it excites kids (young ones) to be creative and pursue the arts in a time when OTHER reality shows make you famous simply for being rude and obnoxious. Idol is the anti-Paris Hilton. As watered-down and anti-art as it is, at least Idol promotes a certain skill.

So there.


poppulse's picture
Posted by poppulse - Wed, 2008-04-16 14:00
Syndicate content

Recent comments